Creative work by the Syracuse University Honors community

What If You Never Left

By Maura Rose

What if you never left

You were always so sweet

Your dress smelled of spices 

Of the most delicious kind 

Your warm motherly aura 

Inviting those around 

You’d smile and beam at them 

You’d give them all your food 

Even when your babies 

So hungrily stood 

You cared so much for friends 

But none for your children 

You were so motherly 

But not a real mother 

 

Your laughter would echo 

In your warm empty house 

You were kind, but not wise

And never stopped to think 

What trauma and fracture 

Your decision would bring 

So, one very sad morning 

You did a haunting thing 

You packed your duffel bag 

Grabbed one of your kids 

And left the other one home 

Your empty house barren 

 

He watched you as you left 

Maybe you said goodbye 

Or did you choose to lie? 

Did you kiss and caress 

And promise you’d return 

Did you leave him watching? 

Leaving his heart to yearn 

 

How could a mother choose? 

Was one better looking? 

Is it something he did? 

If he had loved you more 

Could he have changed something? 

Was your suitcase heavy? 

How much does childhood weigh? 

When you left your own son 

To live with such dismay 

Even in your presence 

He missed the taste of food 

That you would give away 

As he eagerly stood 

Now that you had gone 

Even the smell was missed 

His unbearable sadness 

So easily dismissed 

As the years went by 

Without that tasty smell 

Your boy became rougher 

His childhood spirit fell 

He tried to cry it out 

In the absence of warmth 

His icy tears dried out

 

Why toil for nine months 

Why labor for hours 

Why plant a growing seed 

To not see its flowers

Did you see his first steps 

Flashing before your eyes 

As you stood determined 

To cut with him all ties? 

He didn’t understand 

And no one helped him to 

That handsome little boy 

Grew bitter without you

Never tasting kindness 

Not knowing family love 

Every bit neglectful 

As the mom he didn’t have

 

He started his own house 

Made entirely of cards 

Never showing love 

His heart still had the shards! 

 

He frantically stacked them 

Terrified they would fall 

He was always on edge 

Afraid he’d lose it all 

So, he chased card after card 

To make his home stronger 

But the house was empty 

It had no warm laughter 

 

I live in this card house 

Hungry for laughter 

Starved of affection 

And look at the paradox 

Who set this in motion 

A loving deserter 

A kind and warm thief 

The woman who’s caused me 

A gnawing, haunting grief

 

Standing in the card house 

That my father built me 

I ask of you grandma 

Why you chose this for me 

Where is your suitcase now? 

I desperately need to see 

To search for all the love 

My dad’s hidden from me 

I have burning questions 

I need to understand 

Unzip the suitcase now 

And then remove your hand 

If I can’t find his beating heart 

If I can’t make him love me 

At least in your decades old bag 

I will now finally see 

Just maybe… 

What my life would look like 

If you’d never left me


The author of this piece has chosen to remain anonymous.

 

,