Creative work by the Syracuse University Honors community

What I Meant to Say

By Hannah Beam


What I never said, possibly the simplest sentence in the world, was just lodged in my throat.

There were no seats at the BBB Starbucks, so we stood there awkwardly, hoping chairs might materialize out of pity. He suggested going upstairs to his apartment at Campus West. I hesitated for a second, then nodded. It felt easier than saying no. 

Easier. That was the word I kept landing on lately. Easier to nod, easier to smile, easier to say yes and sort it out later. My stomach knew better. It had already started to knot. His apartment smelled like textbooks, dryer sheets, and slightly burnt toast. The room was too bright for a conversation that already felt heavy. We sat on the couch, angled awkwardly toward each other like two people ready to negotiate a treaty. My palms were damp. I wiped them on my knees and hoped he didn’t notice. 

“I just want to be clear,” I said, cracking my knuckles. “I’m not looking for a relationship or anything. We’re friends, and I don’t want to mess that up.” 

He nodded, but his eager expression didn’t change. “I really like you,” he said. “And I know you feel the same way.” 

Did I? My face went hot. I thought back to November, to all the time we’d spent together. I had enjoyed every minute of it, but I just never asked myself what it meant, and now it felt like I’d let him believe something without ever saying a word. Guilt hit first. Panic followed right behind it. 

I should’ve corrected him, but that might hurt his feelings. Instead, I stared at the ottoman we were using as a coffee table. 

“I just … don’t want to complicate things,” I said. 

It sounded weak even as it left my mouth. Complicate things. Like this was a scheduling issue. He leaned forward, and I leaned back. “I don’t think I can just shove my feelings in a box and keep being friends.” 

“I can,” I said quickly, surprising even myself. 

I didn’t know if it was true. I just wanted the pressure off. He shook his head. “Our friendship isn’t meaningful enough to protect like that. We only really got close in November.” 

That hurt in a way I hadn’t expected. What do you mean our friendship only counted if it led to something romantic? Months of hanging out, and he had weighed it and found it light. 

I felt small, then a little angry, then angry at myself for being angry. I was the one turning him down.

“Well, you’re a senior,” I said, grasping for something practical. “It’s mid-February. You graduate in May. I don’t want to get attached when you’re about to leave.” 

“We’re already attached,” he said. “We both have feelings for each other. And I’d visit all the time. You know my family lives in Utica. My brother goes here.” 

Okay. Got it. So our friendship isn’t meaningful enough to protect, but we are also attached … every reason I offered seemed to dissolve the moment I spoke them. I felt like I was losing an argument I never wanted to have. 

“My ex and I are talking again,” I said, finally putting out a truth that felt concrete. “Things are getting serious, and I don’t want to stop.” 

My heart pounded. It was the only completely true thing I had said so far. I waited for it to end the conversation. 

He paused, then said, “I don’t want you to stop talking to him.” 

I blinked. “What?” 

“I’m just saying,” he continued confidently, “that doesn’t mean we can’t still be something.” 

I stared at him. Something flickered, almost anger, then went flat and heavy. I had finally said the truth, and it bounced right off. Nothing I offered was going to count as a rejection. The walls seemed to be closing in on us. 

“I don’t think that is a good idea,” I said. 

He kept talking, circling back to the same points, reframing everything I said. I shrank into the couch. What I never said, possibly the simplest sentence in the world, was just lodged in my throat. 

I don’t like you like that. 

That was all I had to say, but I couldn’t. 

I knew the sentence. It would have taken four seconds. But I pictured his face when it landed, and my mouth wouldn’t move. I hated that his feelings felt louder than mine. 

Eventually, we ran out of new ways to say the same things. 

“Maybe we should just process this for a week while I’m out of town anyway,” he said. “Think about it.” 

I agreed because it meant that I could leave this horribly uncomfortable conversation. The decision postponed itself. Relief came first. Shame followed right behind it because I knew I was buying time, not an answer. 

On the drive back, neither of us turned on the radio. The car moved through familiar streets. Marshall, Harrison, and Comstock all felt foreign. I watched them go by and tried to look like someone who was fine. When he pulled up to Ernie Davis Hall, I thanked him, unfamiliar and uncertain, the way you thank an Uber driver. 

“Text me,” he said. 

“Yeah,” I said, already opening the door. 

Outside, the air was cold and sharp, filling my lungs, grounding me in a way his apartment hadn’t. My heart stopped racing. 

I replayed the conversation all the way up to my room. Every version ended the same way. Six words. I could have said them in four seconds. 

I told myself I was being kind. That’s what I always tell myself when I nod and mean “no.” But kind to whom? He walked away with a week of hope that I handed him. I walked away with a knot in my stomach and a conversation I would have to have all over again. 

That’s the part I’m still sorting out. I’ve always thought being nice meant keeping people comfortable. Today, it meant leaving him unsure and leaving me unheard. Honesty would have hurt for a minute. This was going to hurt for a week, and it wasn’t even over. 

Next time, I want to say the sentence first. I’m not sure I will. But now I know what it costs when I don’t.


Hannah Beam is a junior broadcast and digital journalism major at Syracuse University, with minors in sport management and Spanish. She serves as President of Otto’s Army, Syracuse’s official student section, and is involved with several student media organizations. She is passionate about storytelling, sports, and finding ways to bring people together through shared experiences.